Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav of the Allahabad High Court stirred controversy with his remarks at a Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) event in Prayagraj on December 8. Speaking on issues such as the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) and majority dynamics in India, Justice Yadav stated that India will function according to the will of its majority.

Key Remarks

Justice Yadav addressed a gathering of lawyers and VHP members, emphasizing the distinction between Hinduism and Hindutva. He said, "Hindus do not expect others to follow their culture but simply demand that it not be disrespected."

He also highlighted Hindu traditions of teaching tolerance and compassion, stating, "We teach our children to love animals and nature. How can a child learn compassion when they witness animals being slaughtered in front of them?"

On majority rule, Justice Yadav said, "This is India, and it will run according to the will of its majority." He added that respect for India's culture, gods, and great leaders is expected from all, even if adherence to Hindu customs, such as performing rituals or taking a dip in the Ganges, is not.

Comments on UCC

Justice Yadav spoke about the constitutional necessity of the UCC, asserting that practices like polygamy, triple talaq, and halala cannot be justified. He referred to the Shah Bano case, where the Supreme Court upheld the right of a divorced Muslim woman to alimony but lamented that the then-central government bowed to pressure and amended the law.

He stated, "Hindu society has eradicated practices like sati and child marriage. There is nothing wrong in acknowledging mistakes and correcting them." He also clarified that the UCC is not advocated solely by RSS or VHP but has the support of the Supreme Court.

Clarification on Religion

Justice Yadav emphasized that his comments were not targeted at any particular religion. "Every religion should introspect and eliminate harmful practices. If they do not, the country will implement a common law for all its citizens," he said.

Praise for Ram Temple and RSS

The judge also praised the construction of the Ram Temple in Ayodhya, calling it a significant achievement. He highlighted the contributions of organizations like RSS and VHP in addressing national issues, stating that RSS will celebrate its centenary in 2025, marking its long-standing contributions to the nation.

Defending His Role

Justice Yadav defended his participation and comments, asserting that as a High Court judge, he is entitled to discuss legal and constitutional matters. "No one can question me for speaking about the law. The media is free to report whatever they wish from my speech," he said.

Reaction and Impact

Justice Yadav's statements have sparked a nationwide debate, with many appreciating his call for introspection within religions, while others criticized his comments on majority rule as potentially divisive. The event has further fueled discussions around the UCC and its implications for India’s pluralistic society.

Other Attendees

Justice Dinesh Pathak also attended the event and inaugurated it but refrained from delivering a speech.